Tom Brady and Peyton Manning are considered the two best quarterbacks of their generation.
Brady is generally treated as the superior of the two, and that’s largely due to his unmatched resume, which is adorned with more Lombardi trophies (seven) than any other NFL franchise.
But according to former NFL linebacker Bart Scott, Manning was the more feared matchup for opposing defense.
“I’d much rather face Tom Brady any day of the week than Peyton Manning,” Scott said on ESPN radio this week. “I think everyone is like that.
“Tom Brady was more about Bill Belichick, the whole team, the execution, that they have a game plan.”
Scott hit both quarterbacks a total of 19 times, hitting Manning five times in the regular season and three times in the postseason. He met Brady 10 times in the regular season and once in the playoffs.
Manning eliminated Scott’s teams twice in the postseason – once in 2006 and again in 2009. Scott’s 2010 Jets beat both Manning and Brady en route to the AFC title game.
“The only thing that was offensive was when he said it was more about Bill Belichick than Tom Brady,” Emmanuel Acho said on Monday’s Speak For Yourself. “Tom Brady has proven that he is a bigger success factor than Belichick.
“Peyton Manning is far scarier. I’ve sat in defensive meeting rooms. This isn’t even a subjective conversation. Based on Peyton sitting in defensive briefing rooms with multiple defensive coordinators on multiple defensive teams, he was significantly scarier.”
Bart Scott: Defenses are more likely to face Tom Brady than Peyton Manning
Bart Scott: Defenses rather face Tom Brady than Peyton Manning
Tom Brady is a seven-time Super Bowl champion, but former Pro Bowl linebacker Bart Scott said, “I’d much rather face Tom Brady than Peyton Manning any day of the week.”
For Acho, both QBs had significant handling of football, but Manning’s was very different.
“Peyton Manning would do you wrong. Tom Brady would just wait for you to be wrong, and there’s a difference. … If someone gets you wrong, you can never be right, but Tom Brady has to wait for you to be wrong.
“When you played Peyton, it was like you were never right.”
“This conversation sounds overblown when you read it in the headlines, but if you delve deep into it, you realize it’s not overdone at all,” Wiley said. “This is just the pulse of the nation. … Let me give you an example.
“We’re playing Peyton on Monday night and he’s been yelling ‘gun!’ the whole first half, which means run right Harrison?” Touchdown. Peyton Manning gave you bait. His head was a calculator on this field. He went out and calculated things. Don’t let that team success mask the fact that if you had to face one, you feared another. And it was obviously Peyton Manning.”
Get more from the National Football League Follow your favorites for updates on games, news and more.
What is Eli Manning record vs Tom Brady?
Eli Manning’s overall record against Tom Brady is 3-2. Two of them are Super Bowl victories. One of the most significant wins Eli Manning has over Tom Brady comes from Super Bowl XLII and the 2007-2008 NFL season.
What’s Eli Manning’s record against Tom Brady? Manning and Brady have had their fair share of the spotlight in key matchups. Manning beat Brady in his two Super Bowl appearances as the Giants won Super Bowls XLII and XLVI. Manning had a 3-2 career record against Brady.
Who’s better Tom Brady or Eli Manning?
Tom Brady victory is the best? Eli Manning is the only quarterback in NFL history to defeat Tom Brady in the Super Bowl, which is no easy feat. Eli Manning’s overall record against Tom Brady is 3-2. Two of them are Super Bowl victories.
Who was better Tom Brady or Peyton Manning?
It would be easy to say that Tom Brady has won seven Super Bowls in ten attempts, a lot more than Peyton Manning’s two wins in four attempts. It goes even further, as Brady won five Super Bowl MVP awards, which is more than Manning’s four appearances in total. Manning also only won one Super Bowl MVP award.
What is Eli Manning’s record loss?
Eli Manning had a career record of 118-118. Not what you are looking for?
Who is the best QB of all time?
Brady becomes the greatest quarterback of all time in NFL history. He has played 264 games in his career. He ranks second in touchdown percentage with 79,204. At the same time, no one in history has surpassed the record 581 touchdowns.
Who has the best QB stats of all time? Who has the best passer rating of all time?
- Races: 98.4.
- Brady: 97.0.
- Crew: 96.5.
- Montana: 92.3.
- Marino: 86.4.
- Elway: 79.9.
Who is the #1 quarterback in NFL?
| QB | last rank | Before. Week |
|---|---|---|
| Aaron Rodgers | 1 | 1 |
| Patrick Mahomes | 2 | 2 |
| Tom Brady | 3 | 3 |
| JustinHerbert | 4 | 7 |
Who Has Tom Brady lost to the most?
the Miami Dolphins. At 24-12, Brady’s dozen losses to Miami are the highest he’s recorded against an NFL team.
Which NFL quarterback has lost the most Super Bowls? Jim Kelly and Frank Reich have lost the most career games by a quarterback in Super Bowls with 4 losses.
What is Tom Brady’s total win/loss record?
| SURNAME | gp | W% |
|---|---|---|
| Tom Brady | 363 | .766 |
Who is a better quarterback than Tom Brady?
Drew Brees has posted similar, if not better, all-around numbers to Tom Brady and is the next QB among active QBs in terms of efficiency and overall passing counts. Drew Brees might be the closest thing to Brady right now among those still competing in the NFL.
